Netanyahu’s endless wars and Eisenkot’s bet on a different Israel

Brigadier General (Ret.) Naji Malaeb*

At the beginning of this year, the founder of Israel's Reichman University, Professor Uriel Reichman, warned that Israel was witnessing a coup against its political system and faced the danger of establishing a dictatorial regime, moving toward a state governed by Jewish law. He pointed out that the government was operating according to the same guidelines followed by all authoritarian coups carried out after World War II, including interfering with the media and seizing public opinion.

In the last elections, current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu received 80% of Jewish votes, reinforcing Reichman's theory that Israel has witnessed a coup against its political system. Will his rival, Gadi Eisenkot's project, be a coup against the coup?

Netanyahu boasts of waging wars on seven fronts, and since the Gaza Flood, he has used more than half of the army's reserves in continuous operations lasting more than three years. He has paid little attention to the losses among regular and reserve forces, both killed and wounded. He even managed to drag the United States into a war against Iran from which it has not yet awakened. If he remains in power, it would not be surprising if Turkey becomes one of his future ambitions, given that his national security strategy aims to defend Israel against any external threats.

I am not here to assess the conduct of the opposition leader tasked with handling internal affairs, who adheres to four principles not far removed from his rival's proposals. What concerns me is how this military figure, if able to form his government, would act concerning Lebanon. The gamble here leads me to Eisenkot's stance during the Israeli army's retaliatory operation in the Gaza Strip.

Whenever the Israeli government makes decisions on war, it consults military and political leaders from the opposition, forming a war cabinet that serves in an advisory role to the Prime Minister.

On November 11, 2023, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agreed with the leader of the opposition National Unity Party, Benny Gantz, to form a national emergency government. The council consisted of three members with voting rights: the Prime Minister, the Defense Minister, and Benny Gantz, the minister in the emergency government. Two observers also participated in the deliberations: former IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot and Strategic Affairs Minister Ron Dermer.

However, on June 9, 2024, Gantz and Eisenkot announced their resignation for several reasons, including the council's inability, despite its members' efforts, to make decisive decisions over a long period. They also cited the lack of necessary strategic decisions to achieve the war's objectives and improve Israel's strategic position and, most importantly, the absence of a clear vision for Gaza's future after the end of military operations. Eisenkot considered that political considerations were obstructing the required military and strategic decisions.

We face the civilian Netanyahu, who adopted combat as his doctrine and applied the motto: "If force doesn't work, stronger force will." Despite the Jewish votes he garnered, he began exacting a toll from Israel for his internal and external wrongdoings, especially in countries supporting him.

The changing position among Americans was evident in the inclusion of the costs of supporting Israel with taxpayers' money as a horse into Congress, despite the abundant outflow from the Zionist-American organization AIPAC intending to topple them.

Nevertheless, he is ready to implement what Washington may decide by continuing military operations, seeking every means to reunite the right by proposing a national unity government under the slogan of existential threat and reoccupying the position of responsibility anew, keeping Lebanon in its current dark circle, with expectations possibly extending beyond that.

Conversely, the bet on Eisenkot is not based on his position from the left or the right, or on the unified stance of Arab MPs in supporting him, but rather on his conduct in leaving the cabinet. This suggests that using the army should be aimed at achieving peace for his country rather than opening fronts endlessly under the pretext of suppressing threats.

Does his position remind us of the approach of Labor Party leader Ehud Barak in 2000, when his electoral proposition to withdraw his army from South Lebanon, which was suffering under the strikes of the national resistance, was one of the reasons for his success?

*Lebanese security and strategic expert

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed by the writers are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Annahar.