Dubai court dismisses AED4.5 million claim between brothers

The Dubai Civil Court of First Instance dismissed a lawsuit filed by a man against his brother and a company he manages. The plaintiff sought the return of AED4.5 million, which he claimed he had loaned to the company to help it overcome a financial crisis. He said he was forced to sell a property worth more than AED7 million to provide the necessary liquidity. He also sought compensation of AED500,000 for damages he claimed to have suffered. However, the court found that the documents submitted did not prove that the transferred amounts were a loan or that the company had committed to repaying them.

The plaintiff stated in his lawsuit that his brother manages a limited liability company in Dubai. The company experienced financial distress that affected its ability to meet its obligations and continue its business. According to the plaintiff, the company sought his assistance to overcome the crisis in exchange for a promise to return the money whenever he requested it.

He explained that he responded to the request for assistance, sold a property he owned worth more than AED7 million, and then transferred a total of AED4.5 million to the company’s bank account to enable it to meet its obligations and continue operating.

He added that he repeatedly asked his brother and the company to return the money, but they refused. This prompted him to file the lawsuit, seeking a joint ruling requiring them to repay the money, together with legal interest at 5 per cent annually. He also sought compensation of AED500,000 for the material and moral damages he claimed to have suffered.

The plaintiff submitted a bank statement showing the transfer of funds to the company’s account, along with a copy of its trade licence and other documents. He argued that these transfers confirmed that he had provided financial support to the company and proved his right to recover the funds.

His brother, who appeared before the court in person and in his capacity as the company’s director, argued that the claim against him personally should not be accepted. He stressed that the company has a separate legal personality and independent financial liability, and that his position as its director does not make him personally responsible for its obligations.

He also denied that the transferred funds were a loan, maintaining that they were payment of a previous debt owed by the plaintiff to the company, rather than amounts received as a loan.

After considering the case, the court clarified that the existence of a family relationship between the plaintiff and the company director, or the latter’s management of the company, was not sufficient to hold him personally liable for funds transferred into the company’s accounts.

The court confirmed that a limited liability company has financial liability independent of its manager. It noted that the documents contained no evidence that any of the funds had been transferred to the brother’s personal account, that he had guaranteed their repayment, or that he had committed a personal error that would justify holding him liable.

The court then concluded that the brother had no legal standing in the case, as there was no proven personal obligation on his part to return the money.

Regarding the claim against the company for the return of AED4.5 million, the court explained that the bank statement, while proving that funds were transferred from the plaintiff’s account to the company’s account, did not establish the legal basis for the transfer. Nor was it sufficient on its own to prove the existence of a loan agreement or an obligation to repay the amount.

The court pointed out that the established principle regarding bank transfers, as set out by the Court of Cassation, is that they are presumed to be made in settlement of a debt owed by the person making the transfer to the beneficiary, unless evidence is produced showing otherwise, such as proof that the transfer was a loan, a gift, or made for another reason.

It further noted that this presumption is rebuttable, but the burden of proof rests with the person claiming that the transfer was made for a purpose other than settling a debt.

The court stated that the plaintiff failed to provide evidence of an agreement with the company to lend it the amount, or of any commitment by the company to repay it on demand. Meanwhile, the company maintained that the money was payment of a previous debt and submitted documents and correspondence in support of its defence.