Abu Dhabi court refuses to hear Dh120,000 used-car claim over odometer tampering because the buyer filed too late

Abu Dhabi: The Abu Dhabi Commercial Court of First Instance ruled not to hear a lawsuit filed by a woman who demanded the cancellation of a car purchase contract worth Dh120,000, the return of its price, and compensation, after she discovered tampering with the odometer.

It was proven that she filed the lawsuit after the legally prescribed deadline had passed, without proving a legitimate excuse or fraud on the part of the seller that would require the application of the legal exception.

The facts of the case are summarised as follows: The plaintiff bought a car from the defendant for Dh120,000. After the purchase was completed, she had it inspected by a competent authority, and an official technical report revealed that there was tampering with the odometer, which contradicts the actual distance traveled and significantly affects the value of the vehicle.

The plaintiff stated that this action constitutes fraud and deception on the part of the defendant, as he concealed a fundamental defect that she could not have discovered at the time of contracting, which prompted her to file the lawsuit. She attached copies of documents, including the vehicle inspection certificate, and demanded the annulment of the sale contract, obligating the defendant to return the amount of Dh120,000 and receive the car, in addition to compensating her with the amount of Dh10,000.

The court explained in its reasoning that it is established in the documents that the plaintiff purchased the vehicle and received it in August 2025, and that the dispute revolves around a hidden defect which is represented in the disparity of the odometer reading to the actual mileage of the vehicle, and therefore the date for hearing the claim for guarantee of this defect is subject to the special ruling contained in Article 108 of the Commercial Transactions Law.

It was clarified that the buyer must notify the seller of any discrepancy or defect within 15 days of actual delivery, and file a claim for cancellation or price reduction within 60 days of delivery. If the defect is latent and not detectable by ordinary inspection, the buyer must notify the seller immediately upon discovery and file a claim for warranty against the defect within six months of actual delivery, unless otherwise agreed upon.

It added that failure to notify the seller or file a lawsuit within the specified deadlines, as the case may be, results in the lawsuit not being heard if there is denial and no legitimate excuse, unless fraud on the part of the seller is proven. In this case, the lawsuit will not be heard after one year has passed from the date of delivery.

The court noted that the plaintiff maintained that tampering with the vehicle's odometer and concealing its true nature from her constituted fraud and deception, which means that she adhered to the exception stipulated in Article 108/2. However, the mere fact that the defect was proven and that it preceded the sale is not sufficient in itself to prove fraud. Rather, evidence must be found that the seller knew about it and deliberately concealed or hid it from the buyer.

The court pointed out that the report of the expert appointed in the case, whose results she was satisfied with, proved that the odometer reading had been changed before the vehicle was sold to the plaintiff, and that the true distance traveled was not revealed by the usual inspection, but the expert was unable to attribute this change to a specific person.

It emphasised that what was proven in the documents, even if it was sufficient to prove the existence of the defect, its age and its concealment, is not sufficient to prove fraud on the part of the seller, and therefore there is no place for applying the legal exception, and the lawsuit remains subject to the six-month period from the date of actual delivery, according to Article 108/1.

It stated that the plaintiff received the vehicle in August 2025, and did not resort to alternative dispute resolution solutions until May 2026, and then filed the lawsuit before the court in October 2026, which means that it was filed after the legally prescribed period for hearing a defect warranty claim had expired.

The court stressed that it is not permissible to apply the period stipulated in Article 510 of the Civil Transactions Law in a way that disregards the special deadline stipulated in Article 108 of the Commercial Transactions Law, considering the latter as the special text regulating the guarantee of the defect and the deadlines for hearing the lawsuit arising from it in commercial sales.

The court concluded that filing the lawsuit after the deadline had passed, and the lack of proof of a legitimate excuse or fraud on the part of the seller, made the plea of ​​inadmissibility consistent with the correct facts and the law, and ruled that the lawsuit should not be heard due to the passage of time.