Advertisement

Opinion
Opinion Saudi Arabia
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Saudi Scholars Debate US Middle East Policy Recalculation

Lead:

Scholars writing in Al-Jazirah over the past three days have shifted focus from abstract strategic analysis to a concrete question: whether the United States is beginning to reassess the costs and benefits of its decades-long military engagement in the Middle East. The debate centers on whether domestic political pressure and economic constraint are now forcing Washington to weigh its commitment to Israel and regional stability against its own citizens' demand for stability, security, and prosperity at home.

Voices & Positions:

In Al-Jazirah, Dr. Abdulrahim Mahmoud Jamous argues that the United States is no longer debating only the scale of military aid to Israel, but rather conducting a wider cost-benefit analysis of American involvement in Middle Eastern wars and conflicts. He contends that after years of resource drain and economic, political, and social fallout, serious questions are emerging about whether Washington will continue on its current trajectory or whether internal shifts are beginning to push toward a reconsideration of core policy pillars.

In Al-Jazirah, Dr. Osman bin Saleh Al-Amer asserts that the international system is undergoing a sensitive transitional period in which the ability of a single superpower to unilaterally direct events is declining, while rising international and regional powers seek to redistribute influence and interests. He argues that the United States, despite military and technical superiority, now faces a world in which economic tools, technology, and information compete with traditional military instruments as drivers of state outcomes.

Tension & Convergence:

Both writers agree that American supremacy is being tested and that traditional power calculations no longer determine geopolitical outcomes alone. They converge on the premise that the Middle East itself has become a site where American assumptions about regional order are under pressure. Where they differ: Jamous frames the shift as a domestic American debate over whether continued engagement serves American citizens; Al-Amer frames it as a structural reordering of global power in which the unipolar moment is ending regardless of American preference.

Editorial Takeaway:

The dominant voice today is that the United States is not simply losing ground in the Middle East, but that American society itself is beginning to ask whether the region remains worth the investment.

Saudi Arabia Brief

Advertisement

All Portals 🇱🇧🇦🇪🇪🇬🇸🇦 كل البوابات Search
Briefer Curator