Advertisement

Opinion
Opinion Saudi Arabia
Friday, September 18, 2026

Saudi Columnist: October 7 Was Analytic Failure, Not Just Intel Surprise

Lead:

Saudi opinion columnists over the past 96 hours have addressed a broad spectrum of concerns: weak governmental administration, Middle Eastern security dynamics, educational performance, institutional accountability, and the commemoration of the 12th anniversary of King Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud's reign. The pieces reflect both celebration of national achievements and critical examination of persistent challenges.

Voices & Positions:

In Al Jazirah, Dr. Abdulraheem Mahmoud Jamous argues that new information emerging about October 7, 2023, reveals the problem was not merely an "intelligence surprise" but a deeper failure of analytical judgment regarding Hamas's capabilities and intentions.

In Al Jazirah, Dr. Muhammad bin Abdulrahman Al Bashir contends that the international community cannot remain passive observers regarding maritime security, particularly at the Strait of Hormuz and Bab al-Mandab, which are controlled by Iran and its militias.

In Al Jazirah, Salman Al Meshlahi examines the protracted confrontation between the United States and Israel against Iran and its proxies, suggesting the conflict extends beyond tactical exchanges to a struggle for regional endurance.

In Al Jazirah, Dr. Abdulaziz Al Jarallah notes that Riyadh's urban development projects under Vision 2030 follow patterns of symmetrical planning with balanced architectural design across northern and northwestern zones.

In Al Jazirah, Mohannadi Al Otaibi focuses on student absenteeism revealed by PISA 2025 data, questioning institutional responsibility for high absence rates rather than attributing the problem solely to students.

In SABQ, an unnamed columnist warns that "loose money" diverted from national conscience becomes fuel for proxy wars and regional security threats across the Middle East.

Tension & Convergence:

Writers converge on the theme that Saudi institutions—from schools to security apparatus—face accountability challenges. They diverge sharply on whether problems stem from administrative weakness (bureaucratic rigidity), external threats (Iran's regional role), or systemic cultural factors (student motivation, writing literacy). Some pieces celebrate government modernization; others critique persistent institutional gaps.

Editorial Takeaway:

The dominant voice today is one of cautious self-examination: Saudi Arabia is modernizing and achieving infrastructure milestones, yet systemic vulnerabilities in education, maritime security awareness, and administrative responsiveness demand urgent attention.

Saudi Arabia Brief

Advertisement

All Portals 🇱🇧🇦🇪🇪🇬🇸🇦 كل البوابات Search
Briefer Curator