Lead:
The Lebanese University faces paralysis as political factions weaponize administrative posts and block governance decisions, while simultaneously, Hezbollah's military posture, the UNIFIL mandate's December expiration, and Iran's leverage over Lebanon's southern security create a cascade of unresolved institutional crises that official unity claims cannot mask.
Voices & Positions:
In Al-Akhbar, an unnamed analyst writes that Israeli military intelligence estimates a "very high probability" that Hezbollah will participate in any new war against Iran, raising questions beyond the party's intentions to the nature of the conflict Israel's intelligence services are anticipating. The assessment reflects ongoing militarization planning rather than certainty of intent.
In An-Nahar, a columnist argues that Lebanon's formal leadership claims unified positions on the UNIFIL succession and UN Security Council alternatives, but leaked statements from Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri reveal immediate fracture: within hours of US envoy Mike Waltz's departure, Berri reaffirmed the Shia bloc's rejection of any framework that codifies the trilateral agreement into international form, undercutting the stated consensus.
In An-Nahar, another writer asserts that transforming the framework agreement into a UN Security Council resolution would require deep structural revision to comply with international law, but the current text remains closer to Israeli negotiating notes than a binding accord—deliberately drafted to impose no Israeli obligations while granting Lebanon nothing, as evidenced by failed demilitarized zones enabled by tacit Hezbollah cooperation.
In An-Nahar, a third columnist contends that the Lebanese University's crisis is not recent administrative failure but structural political capture: factions treat the institution as patronage terrain, holding its council hostage over ranks of full-time professorial positions now inflated to 1,900 from a planned 1,690, turned into a "bazaar and auction" of names from outside the qualified pool.
In Al-Akhbar, a writer states that Israel is unified on the Iranian threat but divided on whether military action is wise, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu potentially wielding the Iran escalation threat to reshape domestic coalition politics and force rivals into a wartime unity government led by him, while opposition figures Gadi Eisenkot and Avigdor Lieberman openly challenge the logic of a full-scale confrontation.
In An-Nahar, an analyst observes that Iranian opposition circles believe the Islamic Republic leadership faces a double bind: war deepens economic strain and state decay while accelerating public anger, yet peace without domestic reform removes a key justification for exceptional measures and security mobilization, leaving the regime uncertain whether to fear conflict or its cessation.
Tension & Convergence:
All columnists converge on institutional dysfunction: Lebanon's official institutions—university, parliament, security arrangements—are hostage to factional allocation and foreign leverage. They agree that public unity statements conceal sharp divisions, particularly over UNIFIL succession and the framework agreement's international embedding.
They sharply diverge on causation and remedy. Columns on the university blame internal political capture; pieces on UNIFIL and Iran implicate US, Israeli, and Iranian strategic interests that dwarf Lebanese agency. University critics suggest procedural reform; regional security writers imply Lebanon cannot resolve the UNIFIL dilemma without resolving the broader regional conflict first.
Editorial Takeaway:
The dominant voice across these pieces is that Lebanese state institutions are tools of factional and foreign power, unable to function independently or speak with single authority, making unified national positions a rhetorical fiction rather than operational reality.