Advertisement

Opinion
Opinion Saudi Arabia
Monday, November 16, 2026

AI Will Not Replace Teachers, Saudi Columnist Argues

Lead:

Ahmed Rafaat Sulaiman, an Egyptian artist and academic, opened an exhibition titled "Istilah" on 8 November 2026 at Odyssey Gallery in Zamalek, initiating broader reflection in the Saudi press on how creative practice intersects with meaning-making. In parallel, writers across Aljazirah and Alyaum continue wrestling with enduring questions: whether artificial intelligence will succeed where film, radio, television, and the internet have failed in displacing traditional education; whether Saudi restraint in regional conflict serves national interest; and how memory shapes identity in the present moment.

Voices & Positions:

In Aljazirah, Dr. Sharif bin Muhammad Al-Atrebi argues that artificial intelligence's promises echo unfulfilled predictions stretching back to Edison's 1913 proclamation that moving pictures would eliminate textbooks within a decade. Despite over a century of technological waves — radio, television, computers, tablets, online platforms — the book, the teacher, and the classroom persist. Each new medium spawned hundreds of studies predicting revolution; none delivered it.

In Aljazirah, Anas Chkala reflects on how objects of negligible material value—old photographs, letters, songs—anchor themselves in memory, allowing us to recover the past without returning to it physically. Memory grants access to vanished faces and ended conversations; yet this same faculty can burden the present by tethering us to what cannot be restored.

In Aljazirah, Ibrahim Abu Hayf contends that artificial intelligence has fundamentally altered institutional reputation management. AI systems now synthesize an organization's history, evaluate performance, and present a summary to new audiences before they visit websites or contact leadership—potentially determining investment and business decisions before human contact begins.

In Aljazirah, Nasir bin Firwan Al-Shraari defends Saudi Arabia's refusal to treat military decisions as automatic reactions to provocations. Strategic restraint deprives an adversary of control over timing and scope; a state that knows its security value does not let others set its national agenda.

In Aljazirah, Abdullah bin Abdulaziz Al-Rabiah, Royal Court Advisor and head of the King Salman Center for Relief and Humanitarian Action, embodies a leadership model in which institutional responsibility carries missionary purpose. His medical background, scholarly precision, and administrative capability converge in a commitment to human dignity that transcends titles.

In Aljazirah, Oboud bin Ali Al Zaahem examines why employees remain silent in meetings when managers invite dissent, suggesting that organizational culture often makes compliance cheaper than disagreement, trapping institutions in decisions that subordinates privately questioned.

In Aljazirah, Abdulrahman Al-Atawi describes Gaza's humanitarian crisis—children shivering under rain-soaked tents, mothers attempting to shield infants from winter cold and water seepage—as an atrocity demanding an end to silence.

Tension & Convergence:

Writers converge on a single premise: human systems—memory, education, institutional hierarchy, restraint—persist despite forces predicted to overturn them. Al-Atrebi and Abu Hayf both acknowledge technological disruption while questioning whether displacement actually occurs; Al-Atrebi sees continuity, Abu Hayf sees transformation in perception management.

Divergence emerges between those defending incumbent systems (education, memory, restraint as strategically sound) and those attending to their human costs. Chkala mourns memory's weight; Al-Atawi refuses humanitarian silence. Al-Shraari's restraint doctrine collides implicitly with Al-Atawi's argument that silence enables atrocity.

Editorial Takeaway:

The dominant voice across these pieces is that institutions and faculties endure not because technology fails but because human need—for meaning, connection, strategic patience, and witness—outpaces technological promise.

Saudi Arabia Brief

Advertisement

All Portals 🇱🇧🇦🇪🇪🇬🇸🇦 كل البوابات Search
Briefer Curator